img, .hide-comment-buttons #singleCommentHeader .formContainer >.title, .hide-comment-buttons #loginButtonContainer display: none; /* Expandable MPU fix */ #side .x300 overflow: visible!important; /* Collapsing Skyscraper fix */ .ad div.skyscraper height:auto!important;padding:0px!important; .ad div#mpu.skyscraper height:600px!important; Immigration as a vote-winner: The two fastest-growing parties are positive about it – Comment – Voices – The Independent Sunday 22 March 2015

Apps

eBooks

i Jobs

Dating

Shop
News
Video
People
Voices Find by writer Yasmin Alibhai-Brown
Rebecca Armstrong
Memphis Barker
Max Benwell
Chris Blackhurst
Ian Burrell
Andrew Buncombe
Ben Chu
Patrick Cockburn
Mary Dejevsky
Grace Dent
Robert Fisk
Andrew Grice
Stefano Hatfield
Lucy Hunter Johnston
Howard Jacobson
Alice Jones
Ellen E Jones
Simon Kelner
Lisa Markwell
Michael McCarthy
Hamish McRae
Jane Merrick
James Moore
Matthew Norman
Dom Joly
Amol Rajan
John Rentoul
Steve Richards
Deborah Ross
Kim Sengupta
Joan Smith
Mark Steel
Janet Street-Porter
John Walsh
Andreas Whittam Smith

Comment
Editorials
Letters
IV Drip
Campaigns Homeless Veterans
Save the tiger
Elephant Campaign
Equal Partners
Delayed Diagnosis
We are Malala
Child Soldiers
Voices in Danger
The New Suffragettes
Rory Peck Awards
British Citizen Awards

Archive
Our Voices The Editors
The Foreign Desk
Battle of Ideas
Rentoul

Commentators Yasmin Alibhai-Brown
Terence Blacker
Simon Carr
Rupert Cornwell
Sloane Crosley
Mary Dejevsky
Robert Fisk
Andrew Grice
Adrian Hamilton
Philip Hensher
Howard Jacobson
Dominic Lawson
John Lichfield
Campaigns
Hamish McRae
Matthew Norman
Christina Patterson
John Rentoul
Steve Richards
Sarah Sands
Mary Ann Sieghart
Joan Smith
Mark Steel
Campaigns
Janet Street-Porter
Andreas Whittam Smith
Voices

Columnists Dom Joly
David Lister
Thomas Sutcliffe
John Walsh
Janet Street-Porter
Chris Bryant

Democracy 2015
IV Drip Archive
Blogs
Scottish independence
Save the tiger
The state of the NHS

Sport
Tech
Life
Property
Arts + Ents
Travel
Money
IndyBest
Student
Offers
Hot Topics Placenta Smoothies Breastfeeding & IQ Wet Wipes Ian Birrell Follow Sunday 15 March 2015
Immigration as a vote-winner: The two fastest-growing parties are positive about it Is it coincidence the two have a positive outlook on this issue, by contrast with pessimism and hostility heard elsewhere in our political discourse?
Share Tasmina Ahmed-Sheikh grew up in a Conservative family. Her father was the first Asian councillor elected in Scotland and as a child she used to deliver leaflets for the Tories. She joined the party at the age of 16, ran a branch of its youth wing in Edinburgh and wore a blue rosette when standing as a candidate for the Scottish parliament – defeated by a young solicitor named Nicola Sturgeon.
Today these two articulate female lawyers are on the same side. Sturgeon, now leader of the Scottish National Party, is her nations first minister. And Ahmed-Sheikh has been picked to fight Ochil and South Perthshire, the partys most winnable seat, at the looming general election. For this Muslim mother of four children, once described as the new face of Scottish Conservatives, defected more than a decade ago in dismay at tough Tory tactics on asylum and immigration.
Ahmed-Sheikh symbolises seismic changes taking place in British politics. If the polls prove prescient, she will sweep into Westminster alongside more than 50 other SNP candidates in May, devastating Labour hopes of victory and demonstrating the skill with which her new party has handled the loss of the independence referendum. Yet she also highlights something else profound that needs to be grasped by floundering mainstream parties: the potential strength of a positive message on immigration.
Read more:
Farage promises Ukip will not ‘stigmatise’ would-be migrants
Immigration to Britain has not increased unemployment
The political party with worse record on ethnic diversity than UkipThe SNP is riding to success and shaking-up politics with pledges to boost immigration. We will welcome people who want to come to work and live in Scotland, proclaimed the independence white paper last year. They favour incentives for migrants to move to remote areas, removing recent restrictions on overseas students staying on to work and ending the edict that people married to Britons must earn high salaries to move here. Perhaps most importantly, they view immigrants as a vital part of Scotlands tartan tapestry of faiths and cultures while remaining fiercely committed to multiculturalism.
What a contrast to south of the border, where the rise of Ukip panicked mainstream parties and sent them flailing around for ways to counter its misanthropic hostility to migration. So they toughened language and tightened policies for fear of looking soft. The conventional view at Westminster is that parties must respond to public anger on this core issue, despite mountains of evidence showing how beneficial new arrivals have been to Britain.
Yet the SNPs stance on immigration is a key part of its optimistic and inclusive outlook that is proving so popular, especially with younger voters desiring political change. At a time when conventional politics is supposedly in decline, the partys membership has risen almost fourfold since the referendum six months ago to almost 100,000 people. This may prove a bubble but it is still astonishing – equivalent to the mass memberships not seen in England since the 1950s – and shows the enduring power of politics to inflame passion.
The six-party election: key figures
Such open attitudes are unusual for a nationalist party, reflecting a tone on immigration noticeably different north of the border among all mainstream parties. Yes, this is partly driven by distinct demographics: the population in Scotland has barely changed over four decades while it has risen by ten million in England. Scots are having fewer children, their society ageing faster. But it is mainly down to political leadership. After all, the two nations share the same nervous sentiments towards newcomers; a BBC poll earlier this month found identical levels wanting to see less immigration and similar levels wanting it stopped.
One other significant British party also shows welcome tolerance on this issue – and that is the Greens, whose policies may be confused but show clarity in their desire to reduce border controls. And like the SNP, they are growing fast with membership soaring from 13,000 a year ago to 55,000 today. Once again, many of these new recruits are young people disenchanted with a sclerotic political system and seeking change.
Is it coincidence the two political parties growing fastest in Britain have a positive outlook on this issue, by contrast with pessimism and hostility heard elsewhere in our political discourse? Perhaps not. After all, pollsters say immigration will not be a major factor in the next election. They point to the huge gap between high levels of people saying it is a major concern nationally and far lower numbers saying it impacts on them locally or in their daily lives. Surveys also show voters are relaxed about foreign investors, overseas students, medics coming to work in the NHS and those fleeing conflict or repression.
This is a time of political ferment – but the strongest insurgency is taking place in Scotland. Ukip made much of the political weather last year and might win five seats in May with its miserable message, yet the SNP is predicted to win eleven times this number. As Sunder Katwala, director of the British Future think tank, says: The biggest gains will not go to the most anti-immigration party in British politics but instead to the most positive.
Ukip helped contaminate politics, pandering to prejudice and encouraging rivals to blame migrants as proxy for persistent failures on public services. Yet attitudes to immigration are polarising, not hardening. This is seen by region, scepticism usually greatest in areas of least diversity, and most especially by generation, with young people far more comfortable over cultural change and globalisation. And these are, of course, the voters of the future needed so desperately by mainstream parties if they are to survive this age of discontent.

When you beloved this article and you wish to acquire details about top eleven token generously check out our own webpage.